CONTACT US
MENUMENU
  • About
    • About Us
    • KEA Serves
    • Careers
    • Client Portal
    • Contact Us
  • Real Estate
    • Commercial Real Estate
    • Auto Dealerships
    • Banking
    • Convenience Stores
    • Hospital & Health Care
    • Industrial
    • Multi-Family
    • Office
    • Restaurant
    • Retail
  • Energy
    • Oil & Gas
    • Midstream
    • Frac Sand & Mining
    • Renewable Energy & Conventional Generation
    • ESG Tax Partnership
  • Services
    • Real Property
    • Personal Property
    • Severance Tax
    • Sales Tax
    • Valuation
    • Incentives & Abatements
      • Chapter 313 School Value Limitation Consulting
      • Chapter 312 Tax Abatement Tax Consulting
  • News
    • Commercial Real Estate
    • Energy

May 25, 2019

Cuyahoga County Property Tax Case: Repayment May Be Coming to Over 3,000 Property Owners

In a final judgment entry released April 16, Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Judge John P. O’Donnell found that members of a class-action lawsuit against the county claiming they were overcharged on their property taxes in 2009, 2010 and 2011 are owed $3.9 million in restitution, plus more than $870,000 in interest. Of that amount, the judge ruled the plaintiffs’ attorneys should be paid 50 percent of it, for a total of nearly $2.4 million. The county has appealed this ruling and the final determination will play out in the 8th Ohio District Court of Appeals.

What Happened?

Every six years, Cuyahoga county undergoes a property reappraisal. In 2006, a business owner by the name of Mark Musial’s had an office that was appraised at $679,500 which he paid taxes on in 2006 and 2007. After the housing collapse shortly thereafter, over 20,000 taxpayers went to the Cuyahoga County Board of Revision and challenged the value of their property. That is when Musial requested a reduction, setting off a chain of events that Judge O’Donnell wrote “was not unique.” About 3,000 property owners won a reduction of their 2008 property values, then had their pre-revision values used in a 2009 appraisal, he wrote. Ultimately, he found that all class members were overcharged for the tax year 2009, and some continued to be overcharged in 2010 and 2011. With Mr. Musial filing a complaint, the board ended up reducing his property value from $679,500 to $499,000.

Judge O’Donnell had very strong words about the case saying, “There is nothing about the sequence of county government mistakes, false assurances, and omissions that would make it remotely fair to bar the plaintiff class members from getting refunds of their tax overpayments for 2009, 2010 and 2011,” he wrote. Ultimately, he determined Cuyahoga County was responsible for making restitution. He found the county had unjustly enriched itself and awarded a judgment to the plaintiffs.

Share:
About KE Andrews
More Posts
  • NY Court of Appeals Levels The Field For Commercial Leaseholders
    NY Court of Appeals Levels The Field For Commercial Leaseholders
    August 15, 2022
  • Montana Property Tax - Supreme Court Will Stay Out of Initiative Case
    Montana Property Tax - Supreme Court Will Stay Out of Initiative Case
    February 7, 2022
  • Santa Clara County Property Taxes - Second Installment Due by April 11
    Santa Clara County Property Taxes - Second Installment Due by April 11
    February 17, 2022
  • Texas Property Tax Info Now Available for Taxpayers
    Texas Property Tax Info Now Available for Taxpayers
    March 18, 2022
  • Proposition 120 Colorado - What Is It?
    Proposition 120 Colorado - What Is It?
    July 6, 2022
Search
Scroll

KE Andrews is a state and local tax firm founded in 1978 that provides services nationwide. Our core business units are property tax, severance tax, and sales & use tax.

CONTACT US

Our Main Office

2424 Ridge Rd., Rockwall, TX

Write Us

Email: contact@keatax.com

Call Us

469-298-1594

Menu
  • Real Property
  • Personal Property
  • Commercial Real Estate
  • Oil & Gas
  • Sales Tax
Copyright @ 2022 - KE Andrews. All Rights Reserved.
  • Home
  • Contact Us
  • ABOUT
    • About Us
    • KEA Serves
    • Careers
  • REAL ESTATE
    • Commercial Real Estate
    • Auto Dealerships
    • Banking
    • Convenience Stores
    • Hospital & Health Care
    • Industrial
    • Multi-Family
    • Office
    • Restaurant
    • Retail
  • ENERGY
    • Oil & Gas
    • Midstream
    • Frac Sand & Mining
    • Renewable Energy & Conventional Generation
  • NEWS & INSIGHTS
    • Commercial Real Estate
    • Energy
  • SERVICES
    • Real Property
    • Personal Property
    • Severance Tax
    • Sales Tax
    • Incentives & Abatements
    • Valuation Services